Elite Health Plans: Consumers Bought What They Thought Was Health Insurance and Found They Had a Discount Card

Elite Health Plans LLC and affiliated entities were charged with operating a deceptive health coverage scheme in which consumers were sold products described as health plans or health coverage that did not provide insurance benefits of any kind — instead offering only discount arrangements that provided reduced prices at participating providers but that provided no coverage for medical costs in the way insurance products do, leaving consumers without coverage when they needed care and facing the full cost of medical services they believed would be covered.DOCUMENTED

The distinction between health insurance and health benefit discount products is fundamental: insurance transfers risk from the insured to the insurer, so that when the insured incurs a covered medical expense, the insurer pays a defined portion of the cost subject to deductibles and cost-sharing. A discount card or health benefit network arrangement, by contrast, provides access to negotiated fee reductions at participating providers but does not pay any portion of the remaining cost after the discount — the consumer is responsible for the full discounted amount. When consumers pay for a discount product while believing they have insurance, they discover the distinction when they receive a medical bill for the full amount after the discount.REVIEWED

How the Marketing Created the Confusion

Elite Health Plans marketed its products through telemarketing and online advertising that used health insurance vocabulary throughout the consumer interaction. Callers described their products using terms like premiums, deductibles, copays, coverage limits, and in-network and out-of-network benefits — the vocabulary that consumers associate specifically with insurance products regulated under state insurance law. The enrollment process collected information about the consumer's health status, medications, and existing conditions in the same way that insurance applications do, reinforcing the impression that the consumer was enrolling in an insurance product.DOCUMENTED

The products themselves were structured around discount arrangements with participating providers and a health benefits network that offered price reductions at certain facilities and for certain services. These arrangements can be legitimate standalone products when marketed clearly as discount programs rather than insurance, but when they are marketed with insurance vocabulary and framed as health coverage, they create a false impression that consumers cannot detect without reading fine print that regulators found was inadequate to cure the misleading overall presentation.DOCUMENTED

The Discovery at the Point of Care

Consumer harm from the deceptive scheme typically became apparent when an enrolled consumer sought medical care and presented their Elite Health Plans identification card at a medical facility. Providers who attempted to verify the coverage found that Elite's products were not insurance and that there was no insurer to bill — the consumer was responsible for the full cost of the visit, subject only to whatever discount the facility participated in through the discount network arrangement. Consumers who had enrolled believing they had health insurance and who had not maintained other coverage found themselves uninsured at the moment they needed care.DOCUMENTED

In some documented cases, consumers had turned down marketplace insurance enrollment or employer coverage during the period they were enrolled in Elite's product, believing Elite's plan constituted adequate health coverage. When the scheme was uncovered and enrollment was halted, some of these consumers found themselves outside open enrollment periods for compliant coverage options and facing a gap period without insurance — a consequence of the deceptive enrollment that compounded their initial financial harm with an insurance access problem that the enrollment timing created.DOCUMENTED

Consumers who presented Elite Health Plans cards at medical facilities were told by billing staff that the product was not insurance — discovering at the moment they needed care that the coverage they had paid months of premiums to maintain did not exist.

Regulatory Action

Regulators obtained a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction halting Elite's enrollment activities and freezing the assets of the entities and principals involved in the scheme. A court-appointed receiver took control of the entities' assets and records to preserve funds for potential consumer redress and to compile an accounting of how consumer premium payments had been used. The principals of the scheme face both civil enforcement and potential criminal referral for the conduct, given that the collection of premium payments for an insurance product that does not exist constitutes fraud under federal and state law.DOCUMENTED

Consumer protection enforcement against health coverage fraud is a priority across federal and state agencies given the direct health consequences of consumers being without genuine coverage. The combination of financial harm — premium payments for a worthless product — and health harm — being uninsured while believing one has coverage — makes this category of fraud among the most consequential for individual consumers that regulators address.REVIEWED

Protecting Yourself from Fake Health Coverage

Consumers evaluating health plan offers should verify that any product they consider is licensed as insurance by their state's department of insurance — a verification that can be done through the state department's online search tools. Legitimate health insurance products are regulated under state insurance law, and the selling company must be licensed in the state where the consumer resides. A product described as health insurance from a company that is not licensed as an insurer in the consumer's state is not insurance, regardless of the vocabulary used in marketing. Consumers who are uncertain whether a health product they have purchased is insurance should contact their state insurance commissioner's consumer assistance line before their next medical appointment.REVIEWED

Have documents relevant to this story? Reach us through our tips channel.